A carbon bomb in Papua: 7 takeaways from our investigation


Primary rainforest in Boven Digoel Photo: Ulet Ifansasti/Greenpeace

This analysis is part of the Indonesia for Sale series. See the full investigations, films and more here.

On 28 November 2018, Earthsight's The Gecko Project, Mongabay, Tempo and Malaysiakini published an investigation into the story behind the Tanah Merah project, a giant oil palm plantation under development in Papua, Indonesia.

The full article, which you can find here, is long, so here are seven key takeaways from it. For the latest updates and news about the Tanah Merah project, click here

The project poses a greater threat to Indonesia’s forests than any other

The project spans 2,800 square kilometres, nearly twice the size of Greater London. It sits at the heart of the largest tract of virgin forest remaining in Asia. To date, only around 2 percent of the area has been cleared. If the project is completed, it will produce as much greenhouse gas emissions as Belgium does by burning fossil fuels in a single year.

The ownership of the project is shrouded in secrecy

The investors behind the project have employed all the tools of corporate secrecy to hide their identities: shell companies with front addresses, fake and proxy shareholders, and offshore secrecy jurisdictions. Today the main shareholders in the companies operating remain hidden behind anonymous companies.

The ultimate owners of four of the seven companies holding permits within the Tanah Merah project are hidden behind anonymous companies in the United Arab Emirates

Permits for the project were issued from a prison cell

The politician who headed the district at the time of the project’s inception was arrested on unrelated corruption charges at a critical stage of the permit process. We discovered he had signed key documents relating to the project from his prison cell on the island of Java, thousands of kilometres away from Papua.

Key permits have been hidden from public scrutiny, in suspect circumstances

Chairul Anhar, the businessman who was central to the Tanah Merah project, also tried to develop a series of vast sugar plantations on a remote string of islands elsewhere in Indonesia. That project was cancelled after illegalities in the permit process were exposed. It has proved impossible to establish whether the same kinds of breaches occurred with the Tanah Merah project, because the necessary documents — the environmental impact assessments (EIAs) — have proved stubbornly elusive. Even local and provincial government agencies with a role in the process claim not to have seen the EIAs. Sources expressed the view that the EIAs are being deliberately, and illegally, withheld from the public.

The activist Franky Samperante, who works with communities in Boven Digoel, has tried and failed to obtain key permits from numerous government agencies Photo: Sandy Watt for Earthsight/The Gecko Project

The project involves two of the world’s most notorious tropical logging firms

Two Malaysian logging firms, Shin Yang and Rimbunan Hijau, are now involved in the project. Shin Yang is a major shareholder in the sawmill under construction, and Rimbunan Hijau is a minor shareholder in a company with land for a plantation. These firms have been at the centre of repeated environmental and human rights scandals in places as far afield as the Congo Basin and Papua New Guinea.

The sawmill under construction on the banks of the Digul River. The notorious logging firm Shin Yang is a major shareholder in the company constructing the mill Photo: Ulet Ifansasti/Greenpeace

The project falls on the land of indigenous people, whose rights have been roundly ignored

The rainforest slated for destruction falls on the ancestral lands of the indigenous Auyu people. The Auyu are heavily dependent on the rainforest for their livelihoods. Villagers living under the shadow of the project say they were pressured to sign documents relating to the project that they did not understand. They told us they were prevented from voicing their opposition to the project due to the oppressive presence of police and soldiers. They told of how one man was “beaten half to death” by a police officer at a meeting held to discuss the project. None of the benefits that were promised to them have materialised.

Auyu children living under the shadow of the Tanah Merah project Photo: Nanang Sujana for Earthsight/The Gecko Project

The project is a test case for whether Indonesia will be able to halt deforestation, with global implications

Large-scale palm plantations have been one of the biggest drivers of deforestation in Indonesia over the last decade. Deforestation, in turn, has been a leading cause of greenhouse gas emissions in Indonesia. Recognising this, earlier this year Indonesian President Joko Widodo announced a freeze on new permits. But the moratorium won’t halt the destruction, because there are many millions of hectares of forest still earmarked for clearance under existing palm permits — those underpinning the Tanah Merah project being the largest example.

However, the president’s order also mandated a review of all existing licenses. Vast tracts of forest could still be saved if cause was found to revoke them. A similar program has resulted in the revocation of thousands of mining permits, and a meaningful review of existing palm permits is essential if Indonesia is to meet its international climate commitments and halt forest loss. Given the globally significant volume of greenhouse gas emissions from deforestation in Indonesia, the implications extend far beyond the country’s borders.

 As of May 2019, The Gecko Project has become an independent organisation in its own right. However, Earthsight is continuing to investigate these issues in Indonesia, and their overseas connections.

More from Investigation

Grand Theft Chaco / The luxury cars made with leather from the stolen lands of an uncontacted tribe

Continue reading
Indonesia for Sale / What we learned from two years of investigating corrupt land deals in Indonesia

Continue reading
The Coming Storm / One year on, temporary halt in deforestation not an end to Congo Basin’s threats

Continue reading
Indonesia for Sale / The secret deal to destroy paradise: The story behind the single biggest threat to the rainforests of Indonesia

Continue reading
Complicit in Corruption / Ukraine PM announces crackdown on rogue timber operations in wake of Earthsight investigation

Continue reading
Complicit in Corruption / How billion-dollar firms and EU governments are failing Ukraine's forests

Continue reading
Indonesia for Sale  / Ghosts In The Machine: The land deals behind the downfall of Indonesia’s top judge

Continue reading
The Coming Storm / New Earthsight report shows Asian governments backing deforestation in Gabon and Cameroon

Continue reading
The Coming Storm / Toxic mix of dodgy firms, impunity and collusion threatens to consign Congo rainforests to the same fate as Southeast Asia and the Amazon

Continue reading
The Coming Storm / Illegal clearance under the guise of old projects, as opacity reigns 

Continue reading

Stay up to date with all Earthsight news & updates

Receive email updates for the latest news and insights from Earthsight and be among the first to read our new investigations.

We keep your data secure and don’t share anything with third parties. Read full terms.