Brazil Supreme Court ruling upholds amnesty to illegal deforesters as cash from bad ag flushes into the coffers of congressmen

28.03.2018

Illegally deforested land shot from a helicopter belonging to Brazil’s federal environmental protection agency

Brazil’s Supreme Court (STF) has upheld several controversial revisions to the Forest Code that will greenwash illegal deforestation and, critics argue, will increase criminal behaviour by ag firms in the Amazon.

Most controversially, the ruling upheld the amnesty granted by the new code to those who illegally cleared in reserves before July 2008. Brazilian civil society has long seen this point as the code’s most problematic provision as it encourages illegal deforestation.

The STF’s ruling means that cattle ranching and crop cultivation can continue in areas illegally deforested before July 2008 without the need for reforestation or payment of fines previously levied by IBAMA, Brazil’s environmental enforcement agency.

The justices also maintained the constitutionality of other provisions deemed to weaken environmental protection in the country, including a new provision that will allow people who previously carried out illegal deforestation to obtain new licenses.

The court’s ruling came as a disappointment to Brazilian civil society. In a critical editorial, the NGO Instituto Socioambiental (ISA) wrote that Brazil will end up with a “weak forest code that is insufficient to promote its potential as a forest country”. ISA also noted, however, that the STF reiterated essential elements of environmental legislation, including the need to protect forests for future generations and to take into account the grave consequences of deforestation to the country’s biodiversity and prosperity.

Greenpeace Brazil expressed concern about the potential for new amnesties in the future. De Olho nos Ruralistas, an advocacy group, observed that the STF’s decision pardons R$8.4 billion (US$2.6 billion) in fines for the illegal deforestation of over 330,000 ha, mostly carried out between 2006 and 2008.

Activists and pressure groups have blamed the powerful influence of the agribusiness lobby in Congress as the main driver behind the new forest code and the recent weakening of environmental protections in the country.

Earlier this year, Reporter Brasil, an investigative media outlet, exposed several congressmen and women, as well as ministers, who had received donations from illegal deforesters. In total, 249 legislators received close to R$59 million (US$18 million) in donations from individuals and businesses that had been fined by IBAMA for illegal deforestation. Reporter Brasil has connected this to recent rollbacks in environmental protections, including the decision to reduce the size of the Jamanxim National Forest.

More from Blog

Yet more evidence has emerged demonstrating the failure of the world’s largest beef companies to cut their ties to forest destruction. This time the accusations are coming not from journalists or activists, but from an important investor

Continue reading
Grand Theft Chaco II / Paraguay Senate seeks accountability from government following Earthsight illegal deforestation exposé

Continue reading
EU anti-deforestation law / Suspect timber firms lobby for certified wood ‘green lane’ in draft proposal

Continue reading
Open letter / Paraguay must halt invasions, deforestation of indigenous Ayoreo lands

Continue reading
FSC hall of shame / The ethical wood label’s long line of scandals

Continue reading
Open letter / Ethical wood label FSC is no longer fit for purpose and must urgently reform

Continue reading
UK Environment Bill / Government proposals to end UK role in driving deforestation overseas must be beefed up for benefits to be realised

Continue reading
Ikea's House of Horrors / Ikea, FSC actions on Siberia illegal logging scandal are a start. In our climate crisis, they must do much more

Continue reading
Grand Theft Chaco / An Illustrated guide to Europe’s role in Paraguay forest destruction

Continue reading
EUTR / Swedish court fines company for Ukrainian timber purchases that flouted EU law, following Earthsight investigation

Continue reading

Stay up to date with all Earthsight news & updates

Receive email updates for the latest news and insights from Earthsight and be among the first to read our new investigations.

We keep your data secure and don’t share anything with third parties. Read full terms.