Papuan government “exercises its discretion” to encourage palm oil company to break the law

30.05.2017

Location of PT Nabire Baru. Photo: West Papua Palm Oil Atlas

The company at the heart of a controversial palm oil development in Papua claimed that the provincial and district governments encouraged it to commit what amounts to a criminal offence because they were “impatient” to see the project begin.

PT Nabire Baru, a subsidiary of Goodhope Asia Holdings, began operating in 2011 without an approved Environmental Impact Assessment, known by its Indonesian acronym AMDAL. Failure to comply with this legal requirement attracts criminal sanctions, including jail time and substantial fines.

In a written response to a range of allegations Goodhope admitted that it had begun land clearing before the AMDAL was approved, but claimed it was pressured by the government to do so and that it had “no option but to commence its operations at minimum levels to satisfy the demands from the government and community”.

Goodhope explains that the government officials were at pains to get the development moving because it was “the only means for social development in the area due to the lack of any other viable socio-economic potentials [sic]”. 

This contrasts with the view presented by NGOs who raised the grievance against the company, who have argued that the company destroyed communities’ sago palms, thereby harming their food security.

Goodhope also wrote that the government agencies were “mutually in agreement” that the decision was “not in line with the legal requirements in Indonesia”. But it was “deemed as not violating the law as the government exercised its discretion” to issue permits.

Goodhope’s explanation for its violation of the Environmental Act was included in a series of lengthy documents made public on 2 December 2016, responding to complaints lodged against the company with the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO). 

On 1 December 2016 Earthsight published a post on the inability of the RSPO to grapple properly with violations of the law, which highlighted the apparent inaction over PT Nabire Baru.

Last month a coalition of NGOs carried out an extensive and scathing analysis of the assessments carried out on behalf of PT Nabire Baru that were intended to demonstrate its compliance with the RSPO standard. 

The NGOs found, among other things, that High Conservation Value (HCV) assessments were “of poor quality or deliberately false”.

The NGO assessment also argued that Goodhope’s operations amounted to “laundering illegally developed land into the certification process”.

On 28 April the RSPO imposed a “stop work order” on seven of Goodhope’s plantations. The RSPO Complaints Panel concurred that the HCV assessments were inadequate and needed to be re-done. However it made no comment on the legal issues.

More from Blog

Environment Bill / Government proposals to end UK role in driving deforestation overseas must be beefed up for benefits to be realised

Continue reading
Siberia / Ikea, FSC actions on Siberia illegal logging scandal are a start. In our climate crisis, they must do much more

Continue reading
Grand Theft Chaco / An Illustrated guide to Europe’s role in Paraguay forest destruction

Continue reading
EUTR / Swedish court fines company for Ukrainian timber purchases that flouted EU law, following Earthsight investigation

Continue reading
У 2019 р. розслідування Earthsight засвідчило, що шведські й італійські фірми імпортували деревину через українську компанію, пов’язану з Віктором Сівцем, який, як відомо, був...

Continue reading
Open Letter / EU transparency needed after key laws delayed



Continue reading
Untamed Timber / Pressure mounts on US, EU to probe Brazilian timber imports

Continue reading
Open Letter / Authorities urged to investigate cases of illegal deforestation in Alto Paraguay

Continue reading
Grand Theft Chaco / An Earthsight response to the environment ministry of Paraguay

Continue reading
У червні цього року Earthsight опублікувала результати детального дослідження, де було показано, як деревина, незаконно заготовлена в одних із останніх європейських пралісів в...

Continue reading

Stay up to date with all Earthsight news & updates

Receive email updates for the latest news and insights from Earthsight and be among the first to read our new investigations.

We keep your data secure and don’t share anything with third parties. Read full terms.